Cloud Computing And Grids

Sam, in his thoughtful blog, says “The Cloud is what The Grid could have been”. Made me think a little bit – actually a lot. IMHO, “Cloud is the next evolution of virtualization” – let me iterate …

  1. Grid is about distributed processing – either task parallelism or data parallelism – i.e. break a problem into small tasks and run them in parallel (task parallelism) or  run the same task on as many data sets as possible & then coordinate the results (data parallelism). Cloud computing is neither. The confusion could be because cloud can be used for HPCC but that is an after effect.
  2. Virtualization, OTOH, is making computation free of spatial and temporal constraints. In fact it also has the property of making computing independent of the hardware and software stack, which is another aspect of cloud computing
  3. Even licensing models become different in the virtualization world, not so in grid models
  4. The most important difference, in my opinion, is the evolution of the VM to support the cloud model. As I had written in an e-mail thread, “while VMWare cannot introduce southbound APIs, they can add Northbound APIs; even some east-west i.e. between VMs for coordination, state et al. IMHO, we have virtualization 2.0 ;o) While hardware mediation and partition layer were the original virtualization propositions – with consolidation and utilization as business value propositions, the charter of the domain has evolved a lot since the advent of “cloud computing”. Mobility of VMs (static or dynamic), the various aspects of HA, management, locality et al plus just plain old resource balancing will necessitate a bigger role (and hence more interfaces, programming models et al) for the lowly VM layer !”
  5. As Sam mentions, Cloud and grid are about location independence (i.e. where the actual computing happen), locality (execute code where data is) as well as mobility (of code and data). Moreover,both have on-demand characteristics – i.e. computing resources can expand (within limits, of course) and more importantly, contact (but less so in the world of grids and more so in the cloud world)
  6. But in many ways, grid is about maximizing the resources, i.e. run in as much (and as many) instances as possible, while the cloud focuses on acquiring just enough resources to perform a computing function, at any point in time, and releasing excess resources – a just-in-time philosophy.
  7. In short, we cannot see Cloud as an extension of grids (because of the similarities in locality – actually non-locality – and elastic nature) but we should look at cloud computing as the evolution of virtualization. This distinction is not theoretical, but there are pragmatic implications – the architecture (the data, control and management planes) and the artifacts thereof, will reflect our conceptual view of the domain. So it is important that we get the conceptual underpinning right.
  8. Grids act on local resources and their predominant problem is scheduling. The focus of cloud computing is resources, processes, systems and data. We can see this from a  simple conceptual view of the cloud domain (shown below)
  9. …even if monkeys are running my data center, I want to make sure they are managed and monitored uniformly (by open standards) and there are lots of bananas for them ;o) And we shouldn’t need to feed different types of bananas for monkeys from different herds …

2 thoughts on “Cloud Computing And Grids

  1. Hi Krishna,

    I admit that first time I read this post I glazed over a bit because of the virtualization focus (I have cared a lot less about virtualization, even 2.0, pretty much since the day I started using EC2). After the second and third passes though, and having written more on the subject, I picked up on two particularly pertinent points:

    – computing is being made independent of the hardware and software stacks, which is arguably a GoodThing[tm]
    – grids focus on maximising performance (and the nuts & bolts, standards, etc.), cloud on getting just enough to do the job, ‘just in time’, essentially doing what needs to be done to satisfy the users’ requests

    On reflection I think both ‘The Cloud is what The Grid could have been’ and ‘Cloud is the next evolution of virtualization’ hold true. Most importantly though, cloud computing is user-centric, focusing on meeting the needs of the user (even if virtualization is a means to that end).

    Anyway I’ve since updated the original post with some content that I think you’ll find interesting (particularly regarding the first point) and added another:

    The case against ‘private clouds’ – a [counter]example.



  2. Pingback: Cloud Computing, Grids and Paczkis - Part Deux « My missives

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s